With the loss, the Terps finish the season with a losing record for the first time since 1993.
The Terps finished in 13th, their best performance at the Big Ten championships since 2018.
After going winless in conference play this season, the Terps are hoping for a different outcome in the postseason.
Reese is fully healthy to help the Terps take home the trophy again.
Brayan Padilla's tying attempt hit the post, and the Wildcats knocked the Terps out in the Big Ten quarterfinals.
The Terps begin play as the No. 2 seed on Thursday.
The Terps' keeper registered four saves and came up clutch in penalties.
Mike Heitzmann's strike helped the Terps walk off the Scarlet Knights with a 5-4 edge in penalties.
The Terps start their Big Ten tournament run with a rematch against Rutgers on Saturday afternoon.
The Terps fell 3-1 in their first matchup with the Buckeyes back on March 4.