Coach Brett Nelligan relied on Osterhout and Rothenbuescher when there were injuries in the Terps' starting lineup.
The Terps have never beaten a team as highly ranked as the Golden Gophers. They posted the fourth-highest score in the history of the program while doing it.
Barber's career high all-around score led the Terps to their highest total mark of the season.
The Terps open up a three-meet homestand on Friday against Nebraska.
The Terps posted season-high event scores on every rotation but still came up short to the Spartans.
Silberman and Tsiknias both returned to the Terps' lineup after months of injury rehabilitation
Barber is currently a top-five scorer in Maryland gymnastics history, and is on pace to move into first place in seven meets.
Despite higher overall scores compared to their season opener last week, the Terps couldn't secure a win against the Scarlet Knights.
The Terps came back from a deficit midway through the Pitt Tri-Meet to down Pittsburgh and Long Island.
The Terps posted their lowest overall score since 2017 but came back from an early deficit to beat Pittsburgh and Long Island.